When Katrine’s Voice Was Gone, the Law Stepped In To Speak for Her

“The estate would have gone to the government … but instead, the money went to someone who truly deserved it. It was a beautiful matter.”
– Paul Falzon

The names and identifying details in the following case studies have been changed to protect client privacy. While certain information has been modified to maintain confidentiality, the situations and outcomes described are based on real client experiences.

Key Facts

  • Matter Type: Statutory Will Application / Testamentary Capacity
  • Estate Value: Around $2 million
  • Capacity Lost: Almost a decade, following a stroke
  • Risk: Estate passing to NSW Government under intestacy
  • Legal Basis: Part 2.2, Succession Act 2006 (NSW)
  • Crown Notified: NSW Crown formally notified and given opportunity to respond
  • Strategy: Supreme Court application for a Statutory Will, supported by medical evidence and affidavits of Katrine’s expressed wishes
  • Outcome: Court order granted, estate secured for her best friend’s daughter instead of the Crown

The Original Situation – An Entire Estate at Risk

Katrine had built a significant estate worth approximately $2 million. Throughout her life, she had repeatedly said the same thing to those closest to her … if anything happened, she wanted everything she owned to go to the daughter of her best friend.

This wasn’t a passing remark … it was a consistently repeated intention expressed over many years to many people she knew well.

But, Katrine had never formalised her wishes in a valid Will. After having a stroke, she had been unable to talk or communicate for almost a decade. Due to her condition, she unfortunately lacked the required Testamentary Capacity to create one.

And, under NSW law, if a person dies without a Will and has no identifiable next of kin, the estate is said to be Bona Vacantia under intestacy rules … meaning it passes entirely to the State.

In short, Katrine’s voice was about to disappear entirely.

Recognising the severity of the situation, her financial planner reached out to Falzon Legal to see what we could do.

The Challenge – Proving Likely Intent Without a Signature

Once we were brought into the matter, we knew we had to ensure Katrine’s wishes were followed. We decided to take a rare and difficult route … applying to the Supreme Court for a Statutory Will.

This is a Will, issued by the court on behalf of a person who no longer has the legal capacity to make one themselves. Complex, and with high evidentiary requirements, we had to show that:

  • Katrine had lost the legal capacity to execute a Will herself.
  • There was medical evidence to support that conclusion.
  • Evidence of her expressed intentions over many years was enough to justify the court making a Will in her name.
  • The proposed distribution to the friend’s daughter was consistent with what Katrine would have done … if she still had capacity.

There was a further complication. Because Katrine’s estate would otherwise go to the State under the Succession Act 2006 (NSW), the NSW Crown had to be formally notified and allowed to respond.

Taking Action With Falzon Legal – Bringing the Matter Before the Supreme Court

Despite the lack of existing precedents and the uncertainty of the outcome, Falzon Legal prepared the application from scratch. Under Part 2.2 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW), we had to show that:

a) there is reason to believe that the person in relation to whom the order is sought is, or is reasonably likely to be, incapable of making a Will, and
b) the proposed Will … is reasonably likely to be, one that would have been made by the person if he or she had Testamentary Capacity

Driven by the desire to see a fair outcome, we:

  • Started urgent litigation – commencing a Supreme Court case to prove Katrine’s likely intentions.
  • Proved lack of capacity – medical reports setting out Katrine’s condition and the evidence of lack of Testamentary Capacity.
  • Demonstrated testamentary intentions – affidavits which demonstrated her desire to leave her estate to her friend’s daughter.
  • Secured the court order – obtaining a legally binding Statutory Will, overriding default intestacy rules in NSW.

‘Most people have never heard of a Statutory Will. The precedents were limited. But the evidence of her intention was clear and consistent, and the alternative, her estate going to the state, was plainly not what she wanted. The court agreed.’
– Paul Falzon

The Outcome – A Fair Result for a Deserving Woman

The application was successful. Instead of the $2 million being taken by the Crown, it was secured for the person Katrine had consistently and clearly said she wanted to have it … her best friend’s daughter.

This lady was a checkout operator at a local supermarket. She received a life-changing inheritance that otherwise would have gone to the government.

Falzon Legal’s prompt, powerful, and bold intervention made sure that Katrine’s savings delivered a legacy that supported the person she loved the most.

Key Takeaways for You

If someone you care about has lost capacity and has never made a Will, or allowed an existing will to lapse, it might not be too late for a Statutory Will. But the application is complex, the evidence requirements are strict, and the right outcome is never guaranteed.

Katrine had means, she had clear wishes, and she had a person she loved. In fact, she had everything … except a valid Will. The key lesson from Katrine’s story is the most basic one in Wills and Estate Law … write a Will while you still have capacity.

What You Should Do:

  • Make a valid Will as early as possible while your wishes are clear and legally binding.
  • Review and update your Will regularly to reflect your relationships and intentions.
  • Put your intentions in writing with the guidance of a solicitor, informal wishes usually aren’t enough.
  • Ensure Powers of Attorney and Enduring Guardianship are in place … in case you lose capacity.

What You Should Do:

  • Make a valid Will as early as possible while your wishes are clear and legally binding.
  • Review and update your Will regularly to reflect your relationships and intentions.
  • Put your intentions in writing with the guidance of a solicitor, informal wishes usually aren’t enough.
  • Ensure Powers of Attorney and Enduring Guardianship are in place … in case you lose capacity.

How Falzon Legal Can Help

If you’re facing a similar issue, or want to ensure your wishes are followed, your wellbeing is protected, and your loved ones receive their rightful inheritance … get in touch with Falzon Legal:

Case Related Statutory Will and Intestacy FAQs

What Is a Statutory Will in NSW?

A Statutory Will in NSW is created by the Supreme Court. It’s for someone who doesn’t have the mental capacity (for example, because of dementia or disability) to make their own Will. It can make sure that a person’s intentions are followed and intestacy rules are avoided.

Who Can Apply for a Statutory Will in NSW?

Anyone can apply to the Supreme Court for a Statutory Will for someone who lacks Testamentary Capacity and is still alive. The applicant must have a genuine interest in the welfare of the person on whose behalf the application is made.

What Happens if Someone Dies in NSW Without a Will and Has No Family? Understanding Bona Vacantia.

Under NSW intestacy rules, the estate goes through a set order of relatives. And, if no living relatives can be found, the estate will go to the NSW Government.

Is It Too Late To Make a Will Once Testamentary Capacity is Lost?

If someone loses Testamentary Capacity, they cannot legally make a Will. A Statutory Will application can, however, be made to the Supreme Court of NSW. The sooner this is done, the better the chances of success.

You may also be interested in other Falzon Legal Case Studies

Case Study Overview

What happens to a lifetime of savings when there’s no Will and no living relatives? For Katrine, the answer was that almost everything would go to the government. After a stroke left her unable to communicate for nearly a decade, she lacked the capacity to sign legal documents, leaving her estate in a dangerous legal position.

Client:
Katrine (via her financial planner)

Matter Type:
Statutory Will Application / Testamentary Capacity

Location:
Sydney

Estate Value:
Around $2 million

Risk:
Without intervention, the entire estate passes to NSW
Government under intestacy

Outcome:
A successful Supreme Court order creating a Court Will

24/7 Support
02 6610 9964

For trusted and compassionate expert legal advice.
Get In Touch